* "51
percent of Americans say they'd support a law replacing the
death penalty with mandatory life; 46 percent would oppose such
legislation."
The word "capital" in "capital punishment" refers
to a
person's head. In the past, people were often executed
by severing their head from their body.
Most Americans believe tht life
in prison is a more reasonable and
practical sentence than judicial homicide. And neither
represent
a majority. We can, indeed, do better. Every other western
inductrialized democracy has done
so, and it is time we joined them.
Here is the documentation:
Declining Support for Kentucky's Death
Penalty
An editorial published by the
Lexington Herald-Leader noted that support for Kentucky's death
penalty has declined since the state resumed executions a decade
ago. The paper stated that 68% of state residents
questioned in a recent poll preferred a long prison sentence
over execution for those convicted of murder. The Herald-Leader
concluded that Kentuckians' growing unease about capital
punishment is reflective of a broader national trend away from
the death penalty and that the death penalty is often more a
matter of chance than of justice.
By Peter Smith
psmith@courier-journal.com
The Courier-Journal
More than two-thirds of Kentuckians
surveyed say that a lengthy prison
sentence is the "most appropriate"
punishment for someone convicted of
aggravated murder, while about a
third chose the death penalty, according to a
University of Kentucky poll.
And in Ohio:
59% would support an alternative
to execution if it involved life in prison without chance of parole
and a requirement that the inmate work while in prison with the
money going to the victim's family. 31% supported the death penalty
in preference to this alternative. An inmate working 40
hours a week, 50 weeks a year, over a 25 year sentence at $3.00 an
hour would generate $150,000 for the family of the victim.
And the most recent national poll indiates a
Majority who favor life in prison over death
An ABCNEWS/Washington Post poll finds broad agreement
with two other arguments against the death penalty: That it's
applied unfairly across jurisdictions, and that innocent people are
sometimes executed. And the strongest argument in favor — that it
prevents killers from killing again — is also achieved by life in
prison without parole.
*Life
Given these views, 51 percent of Americans say they'd support a
law replacing the death penalty with mandatory life; 46 percent
would oppose such legislation. Equal numbers would support it
"strongly" as oppose it strongly — about a quarter on each side.
Fifty-one percent also say they'd support a nationwide moratorium
on the death penalty while a commission studies whether it's been
administered fairly. And when people are told that such a moratorium
currently exists in Illinois, support for a national moratorium
advances to 57 percent.

Support or Oppose
 |
| |
Support |
Oppose |
|
Law
replacing death with life/no parole |
51%
|
46
|
|
National
moratorium on death penalty |
51 |
43 |
|
National
moratorium (Illinois noted) |
57 |
46 |
|
And here are
the facts
"The death penalty costs more, delivers less,
and puts innocent lives at risk. Life without parole
provides swift, severe, and certain punishment.
It provides justice to survivors of murder victims
and allows more resources to be invested into
solving other murders and preventing violence.
Sentencing people to die in prison is the
sensible alternative for public safety and murder
victims’ families."
and more:
Mario Cuomo, Former Mayor of New York City,
in a June 17, 1989 article for the New York Times
titled
"New York State Shouldn't Kill People," wrote:
"What makes the risk of wrongful execution all the more
unacceptable is that there is an effective alternative to
burning the life out of human beings in the name of public
safety. That alternative is just as permanent, at least as
great a deterrent and - for those who are so inclined - far
less expensive than the exhaustive legal appeals required in
capital cases.
That alternative is life imprisonment without the
possibility of parole. No 'minimums' or 'maximums.' No time
off for good behavior. No chance of release by a parole
board, ever. Not even the possibility of clemency. It is, in
practical effect, a sentence of death in incarceration.
Life without parole is achievable immediately. The
Legislature could enact it Monday. I would sign the measure
Tuesday. It would apply to crimes committed the next day. In
fact, the only thing preventing the next cop killer from
spending every day of the rest of his life in jail is the
politics of death."
and here is some
interesting commentary from a more mature nation
Life in Prison: A Fate Worse than
Execution?
August 1, 2007
For those of my readers who advocate the
death penalty as the ultimate punishment — the ultimate
justice — for the ultimate crime, I have a quote for you:
We are tired of dying a litttle bit
each day. We have decided to die once and for all, and
we ask that our penalties of life imprisonment be
converted to penalties of death. To be now dead but not
alive either — life imprisonment turns light into
shadow, it kills you inside bit by bit: a death in small
doeses. It renders life useless, makes the future seem
the same as the past. It crushes the present and takes
away hope. To a life prisoner, only life remains. But
life without a future is less than nothing. It is flat
and everlasting. Life imprisonment is the invention of
an Antichrist with a malice that transcends the
imagination. It is a victory over death, stronger than
death itself.
This impassioned plea comes from 310
Italian murderers serving life sentences. Italy has no death
penalty.
I advocate for an abolition of the death penalty ... it’s
expensive and potentially cruel and unusual — see the
research done on lethal injection methods —
Finally, I don’t believe that the state
should have the right to kill people in any situation
outside wartime.
But for those of you who believe that life
in prison is letting murderers off easy, look at the 310
murderers who are begging for a release from their
life-sentence torment via the very means you advocate as
their ultimate punishment. Perhaps it’s time to rethink
whether the death penalty is more than the lowest of the low
deserve.
Food for thought.
best regards, Tim
|